Start with what isn't changing
Choose your cabinet color last, after you know which counters, backsplash, floor and appliances are staying. Those surfaces have their own undertones, and the cabinet color has to work with them. Most color regrets come from choosing a color from a chip in the store and only seeing it next to the granite once the doors are back on.
Before you look at a single paint chip, stand in your kitchen and note:
- Countertop: its main color, and the color of the flecks or veins. Granite with gold and brown in it is warm. Most white quartz is cool.
- Backsplash: tile color, and the grout color, which often matters more than people expect.
- Floor: warm wood, gray plank, tile.
- Appliances: stainless, black, white, or a mix.
- Light: which way the windows face, and whether your bulbs are warm or cool.
Those notes narrow the choice faster than anything else. Once the color is settled, the rest of the job is the same; see how we paint cabinets in St. Joseph for the full process.
Whites aren't all the same color
Every white has an undertone, and choosing a white for cabinets is really choosing the undertone. Warm whites lean yellow, cream or slightly pink. Cool whites lean blue or gray. A bright white has very little of either and can look stark.
That's why a white that looks perfect in one kitchen fails in another. A warm white next to white quartz with cool gray veins can make the quartz look dingy, or the cabinets look yellow. A cool white next to a granite full of tan and gold can look cold and blue. Hold a painted sample against the counter you are keeping. The one that makes the counter look clean is the right white.
Color families that work on cabinets
Five color families cover nearly every painted kitchen, and each one does something different to a room.
Whites and off-whites. The broadest choice, and the easiest to live with. They brighten a dark kitchen and sit well with almost any counter, once the undertone is right.
Greige and taupe. Gray mixed with beige. These soften a kitchen without making it look dark, and they forgive fingerprints and dust better than white. They work well when a warm countertop and cool stainless appliances share a room.
Greens. From muted sage to deep olive and forest. Lighter greens feel calm and pair well with wood floors and brass hardware. Deep greens work best on lowers or an island, with a lighter color above.
Navy and deep blue. A strong choice for islands and lower cabinets. Deep blue looks especially good next to white counters and brass or polished nickel pulls. In a small kitchen with little daylight, use it on part of the kitchen rather than the whole thing.
Black and charcoal. Dramatic and modern, especially in matte or satin. Dark colors show dust, fingerprints and any flaw in the surface underneath, so the prep has to be perfect. On oak, dark colors also show the grain more.
Two-tone kitchens
The most common two-tone layout is a darker color on the lowers or the island and a lighter one on the uppers. It keeps the dark color low and the room bright, while giving the kitchen a focal point. A painted island in a contrasting color is the simplest version, and the easiest to change later.
A second color does add cost. It means separate primer tinting, separate masking and a separate set of finish coats. Our St. Joseph cabinet painting cost guide covers what a second color adds, along with the other factors that raise or lower a price.
Sheen: satin or semi-gloss
Most painted cabinets are satin or semi-gloss, and the choice is between hiding flaws and easy cleaning. Satin has a soft, low sheen. It hides small imperfections in the wood and the prep, and it cleans well with a damp cloth. Semi-gloss is shinier and wipes clean a little more easily, but it shows every dent, sanding mark and bit of grain underneath.
| Sheen | Look | Shows flaws | Cleaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Satin | Soft, low shine | Hides small flaws | Wipes clean with a damp cloth |
| Semi-gloss | Noticeable shine | Shows dents, grain and brush texture | Wipes clean slightly more easily |
Matte and flat finishes look beautiful, but they mark more easily, so we suggest them only for kitchens that don't see heavy use. Sheen names also vary between manufacturers. One brand's satin can be shinier than another's, which is one more reason to look at a painted sample.
Color on oak grain
Dark colors and higher sheens make oak grain more visible. Oak has open pores that show through paint as a texture, and light catching a shiny dark surface picks out every pore. A light color in satin shows the least grain, while black in semi-gloss shows the most. If you are painting oak and want the grain to disappear, read our guide on painting oak cabinets and whether the grain will show before choosing a color.
How to sample a color
Look at a painted sample in your kitchen, next to your counter, in morning and evening light, before deciding. A small chip is not enough. Paint a sample board or a spare cabinet door, at least the size of a sheet of paper, in the actual cabinet enamel and sheen you are considering.
- Stand it on the counter, against the backsplash.
- Look at it in the morning, in the afternoon and in the evening with the lights on.
- Hold it next to the floor and the appliances.
- Put two finalists side by side. The difference between two whites often only shows up next to each other.
Honey oak, cherry and espresso kitchens
Each of the three most common stained kitchens paints differently, so it helps to know what to expect from yours.
Honey oak. The classic 1990s builder kitchen. It paints well, but the grain will show unless it is filled, and the orange tone needs a stain-blocking primer so it doesn't show through light colors. Whites, greige and green all work.
Cherry. Usually smoother grain than oak, so it paints with a flatter finish. Cherry's red tones need full primer coverage under a light color. Painted cherry kitchens often keep a warm counter, which suits warm whites and greens.
Espresso or dark stain. These are usually smooth maple or birch under a dark finish. Going light means more coats of primer to cover the dark base, but the finish comes out smooth. The dark color often hides chips and wear that show up during prep, so expect some repair.
Cabinet color questions
Do white cabinets yellow?
Some do, over time. Oil-based enamels yellow with age, especially where there is little daylight. Waterborne and hybrid cabinet enamels resist yellowing much better. Grease and smoke can also tint white cabinets slightly, and regular cleaning removes most of that. A stain-blocking primer stops wood tannins from showing through.
Can you color-match a cabinet from another brand?
Yes. Give us the brand and the color name or number, and the enamel can be tinted to match. If you only have a cabinet or a door to match, a paint store can scan a sample. Either way, see a painted sample next to the original, because sheen and product change how a color reads.
Should the island be a different color?
It's a good place for a second color if you want one. A contrasting island gives the kitchen a focal point without darkening the whole room, and it is the simplest two-tone layout to live with. Pick the island color after the main color, and make sure both work with the same countertop.
Get a quote with your color in mind
Tell us the color you are considering when you send photos of your kitchen, and we will include it in your written quote. Get a Quote
Rated 4.6 from 37 Google reviews